Every Actress That Almost Played Andy in ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ Before Anne Hathaway Landed the Role (One Actress Turned Down the Role 3 Times!)

The cinematic landscape is dotted with iconic performances that seem predestined, yet the journey to an actor landing a career-defining role is often fraught with unexpected turns and near misses. Such is the fascinating tale behind Anne Hathaway’s indelible portrayal of Andy Sachs in the beloved film ‘The Devil Wears Prada,’ a role that, surprisingly, almost slipped through her grasp. Despite the film’s enduring popularity and the critical acclaim Hathaway received, it has been revealed that her casting was far from a foregone conclusion, underscoring the often-unpredictable nature of Hollywood casting.

Indeed, during an appearance on ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race’ in 2021, the Oscar-winning actress herself confessed a stunning detail: she was, in fact, the ninth choice for the part of the aspiring journalist who unwittingly finds herself plunged into the cutthroat world of high fashion. This revelation highlights the extensive and rigorous auditioning process that goes into major movies, where countless talented individuals vie for a single role, and studios meticulously weigh their options before making a final decision. The notion that an actress now synonymous with a character was initially so far down the list offers a compelling glimpse into the behind-the-scenes machinations of the entertainment industry.

‘The Devil Wears Prada’ captivated audiences worldwide, largely due to its sharp wit, relatable character arcs, and the electric chemistry between its lead performers, particularly Anne Hathaway as Andy Sachs, Meryl Streep as the formidable Miranda Priestly, and Emily Blunt as the sardonic Emily Charlton. Hathaway’s nuanced performance perfectly captured Andy’s initial naiveté, her subsequent transformation, and her ultimate moral reckoning, making her a relatable anchor in a world of high-stakes glamour and demanding personalities. Her portrayal cemented Andy Sachs as an iconic figure in pop culture, a testament to her acting prowess and the profound impact of apt casting.

Before Hathaway ultimately secured the role, a considerable list of prominent actresses were reportedly considered for the coveted part. Among these highly sought-after talents, one particularly notable name stands out for an extraordinary reason: she is said to have outright rejected the role not once, but an astonishing three times. This unprecedented refusal speaks volumes about the diverse considerations actors weigh when selecting projects, whether it’s scheduling conflicts, perceived fit for the character, or simply differing creative visions, and further complicates the intricate tapestry of Hollywood decision-making.

While the identities of all the actresses who almost played Andy have been a subject of much speculation within entertainment circles, the story of the actress who repeatedly declined the part adds a layer of intriguing complexity to the film’s production history. It illustrates that even with a strong script and an iconic co-star like Meryl Streep, securing the perfect ensemble can be a challenging endeavor, requiring persistence from the filmmakers and a fortunate alignment of stars. The journey to the final casting decision for ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ was clearly a marathon, not a sprint.

Ultimately, the decision to cast Anne Hathaway proved to be a pivotal one, instrumental in shaping the film’s tone, enhancing its emotional depth, and securing its lasting appeal. Her performance transcended mere acting, infusing Andy Sachs with a blend of vulnerability and resilience that resonated deeply with viewers. ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ transcended its initial genre to become a cultural phenomenon, a perennial favorite that continues to define fashion and workplace dynamics for new generations, a success story that undeniably hinges on the precise and serendipitous selection of its lead. This behind-the-scenes look at the movies’ casting process underscores how fundamental choices can profoundly influence a film’s trajectory and legacy in cinematic history.